Abertay Uni debate shows momentum with Yes

On 23 September, Stuart Hosie MP (SNP) and Lord George Robertson, former leader of the Scottish Labour Party, debated the motion "It is time for Scotland to become an independent nation state" as part of Dr Wallace McNeish's Thinking Lecture series at Abertay University.

At each of Dr McNeish's lectures an audience vote is taken before the debate begins and again once it has ended, before comparing the two results.

Prior to the debate the audience vote (viewable in the video at around 6:30) was:

  • Yes: 21%
  • No: 59%
  • Don't Know: 20%

The vote taken after Mr Hosie and Lord Robertson had made their cases (viewable in the video at around 1:27:00)  was:

  • Yes: 51%
  • No: 38%
  • Don't Know: 11%

This proves once again that the momentum is with the Yes campaign, and that the more people become engaged with the debate and the positive message of independence, the more likely they are to vote Yes in September 2014.


  • Only a Yes vote can deliver job-creating powers

    After First Minister Alex Salmond's decisive win against No campaign leader Alistair Darling in the BBC referendum debate - winning by 71 per cent to 29 per cent in the post-debate ICM/Guardian poll - Yes Scotland Chief Executive Blair Jenkins said that...

  • Support for a Yes vote on September 18 has been given a major boost following the Alex Salmond-Alistair Darling TV independence debate, fresh analysis of polling data has shown.

    Crucially, undecided voters - who will play pivotal role in the outcome of the referendum – judged the First Minister to be the clear winner...

  • Winning with the undecided

    Amongst people who were Don’t Know at the end of the debate, the First Minister was seen as winning the debate by 74% to 26%. For those who were undecided before the debate the figures were 55% for the FM to 45% for Mr Darling.

  • The Yes Scotland campaign said it was “looking forward” to the first televised debate between First Minister Alex Salmond and No campaign chairman Alistair Darling, on STV on Tuesday evening.

    In advance of the debate, the Yes campaign drew attention to the most recent poll figures on leadership approval ratings -...